KRISTIN
Welcome to Healthcare Workforce Unplugged, a Medical Solutions podcast. I’m your host, Kristin Dahl.
If you’ve ever felt like you’re carrying the full weight of workforce challenges on your own, today’s conversation is for you. For many healthcare leaders, workforce management doesn’t feel strategic. It feels constant: constant coordination, constant problem-solving, constant pressure. And too often, the partners meant to help are sitting on the sidelines instead of carrying that weight with you.
In this episode, we’re talking about what healthcare leaders need from a workforce partner and why the difference between a vendor and a true partner changes everything. I’m joined today by three incredible leaders who bring different perspectives to this conversation.
First, Karin Selfors, Chief Client Officer at Medical Solutions, partners closely with health systems across the country to design workforce strategies that go well beyond traditional staffing.
Next, Natalie Red Eagle, Vice President of Clinical and Quality Services at Medical Solutions, brings a clinical lens, connecting workforce strategy directly to quality outcomes and patient care.
And Dr. Charles Dolan, Vice President of Clinical Operations at TidalHealth, offers the provider-side perspective. With decades of healthcare leadership experience and more than 30 years as a paramedic, he grounds this conversation in real-world operational and frontline insight.
Thank you all for being here today.
KARIN
Thank you.
NATALIE
Thanks for having us.
- DOLAN
Thank you.
KRISTIN
Between the three of you, there’s a lot of experience in how workforce decisions actually play out, both operationally and on the ground, so I’m really looking forward to this conversation.
Let’s start at a high level. We hear a lot about moving from a vendor relationship to a true partnership, but that shift means different things depending on your role.
Dr. Dolan, from your perspective, what does a true workforce partner look like to you today? And how is that different from what you may have experienced in the past?
- DOLAN
Yeah, that’s a great question. I think one of the challenges coming out of COVID was the workforce was just a mess. And so, for me, trying to run a health system, we need to have a partner, not someone that’s just a vendor, kind of to what you were alluding to.
I think the challenge for me was we had to find the right person, the right team, and the right organization. I think of workforce vendors in the past as transactional. We would send them a requisition, they would find someone, and we would fill the gap.
What we need today, and what my teams need today, is a partner. Somebody that’s fully integrated into our system, where you can’t tell that they work for an outside entity. To me, that’s what’s really important. It’s seamless.
I don’t want nursing leaders to be stressed trying to get their requisitions, interviews completed, clinical reviews, and all those things that have to happen in order to bring in temporary labor. So for me, and for them, it needs to be fully integrated, operational, and easy.
KRISTIN
Yeah, absolutely. That’s such a great perspective.
Karin, I’d love to get your take on this because you’ve worked with many of the healthcare leaders in our client base. From what you’ve seen, how have expectations from healthcare leaders changed when it comes to workforce partners?
KARIN
Dr. Dolan just said a lot of really great things. I’m smiling because I am definitely experiencing many of the things he was mentioning across the health systems that we work with.
First of all, what we’re observing is our clients prefer to work with fewer partners rather than many. I would say there’s a lot of consolidation ongoing. That’s one trend we’re definitely seeing.
And I think that ties really nicely into what you said, Dr. Dolan, moving from a transactional vendor to a strategic partner. If you have fewer partners, you want to have more strategic partners.
On top of that, you want those partners to truly understand your organization, your pain points, and your issues. And you want them to help you solve those issues. So I truly see that evolution from a transactional vendor to a consultative relationship.
KRISTIN
Yeah, that makes perfect sense.
Natalie, I feel like you’re the perfect mix here. You’ve been on the floor experiencing some of the same things that Dr. Dolan mentioned, and you’ve also worked with many healthcare leaders in your current role.
From your time with clinical teams and as a clinician yourself, can you explain what you’ve heard in terms of frustrations with traditional staffing agencies and maybe talk a little bit about the disconnect between what hospitals need and what they’re actually getting from some staffing partners?
NATALIE
Absolutely. And I second everything Dr. Dolan and Karin have said so far.
I think what’s interesting from my lens is I’ve worked both sides of this. I was in acute care nursing for a decade, and I still actually moonlight there. And then I’m in healthcare staffing leadership as well. Seeing both sides has been so fascinating.
From a broad industry perspective, we are seeing the need to shift into a true partnership and away from transactional staffing. And that became the trend during the pandemic, as Dr. Dolan said. People were just trying to fill quick needs. A lot of times, speed took precedence over quality, and we felt that on the floor. Your nursing personnel and your clinicians totally felt that.
What we’re seeing now is that the most successful staffing companies are the ones who were invested all along, who understand their facility partners’ KPIs, the financial realities that they live in, that roller coaster, the clinical goals they set for themselves, regulatory standards, and are committed to supporting them through the entirety of that, not just filling shifts.
KRISTIN
Yeah, absolutely. I’m sure that a lot of this has resonated with our listeners.
One of the other themes that we hear quite a bit about is that true partners don’t sit on the sidelines. Dr. Dolan mentioned that a little bit. They embed themselves in their organizations.
Karin, would you mind talking a little bit about what that actually looks like to be embedded in a health system’s operations?
KARIN
Yeah. It’s easier said than done, I’m going to say, because you do need a willing client or a willing partner that is openly willing to share a little bit more of what’s going on under the covers, or under the hood. And for that to happen, you have to build a trusting relationship as a foundation first. That doesn’t happen from day one.
When we achieve that, when we achieve being a trusting partner and we can be more honest and open with each other and share information, then we essentially become an extension of the teams of the healthcare systems or clients that we have. And that’s the best of all, right? If we can be an extension and work alongside clinical, HR, or operational leaders in helping them achieve their goals.
For that to happen, we do need to understand their operations. We need to understand the environment that they live in. So it all boils down to being present and engaged and being that consultative partner, and really going from being reactive and transactional to being strategic.
But like I said, I think the bottom line is to be embedded, you have to earn that trust. You have to be open and honest with each other and exchange information for that to happen.
KRISTIN
Dr. Dolan, back to you. From your standpoint, why does that level of integration matter?
- DOLAN
For us as a health system, it matters because we are very busy. All managers, leaders, vice presidents, no matter who you are, clinical staff, everyone’s busy.
We’ve had something in our area that we’re not seeing everywhere around the country. Our volumes have never decreased. It’s only gotten worse. So we’re busy.
I think what our team is looking for and what we need from our integrated partner is a way to quickly navigate getting the help the team members need, with gentle pushback from our partners when needed, and maybe some guidance because sometimes we think we know everything as health systems, and we do not.
We need our integrated partner to do that. Our leaders tell me all the time how easy the process is here at TidalHealth. It’s a completely electronic request process. It goes through our internal processes to be approved, and then it seamlessly just happens.
I think that is what teams are looking for. They need seamless, painless, fast, integrated partners to help us get this work done. And honestly, it has to be that way.
For our clinical leaders, it is not like it used to be. They’re busy. They’re in staffing. They’re taking groups. So the expectation for them to have to screen every applicant just doesn’t exist.
You can’t do those activities without an integrated partner who understands what each unit’s clinical needs are, maybe the patient populations. That’s why this integrated partner, and not just a vendor, is critical.
It’s something that we demand. It’s something that I demand as a vice president of our health system. I wouldn’t partner with anyone who wouldn’t be willing to do that level of activity. For me, that’s what we have to do. And our teams love it.
I get great feedback all the time on this integrated partner relationship that we’re talking about.
KRISTIN
Things are always getting busier and never slowing down.
Another key shift that we’re seeing is moving away from one-size-fits-all solutions and listening before solving issues.
Natalie, how does that show up when you’re thinking about clinicians and quality?
NATALIE
When I think about clinician and quality perspectives, it’s incredibly complex. And I love that Dr. Dolan talked about this and what we’re doing well, because it really is on the partnership, but also the staffing agency, to absorb that complexity and make it simple for the facility partner, or at least as simple as it can be.
Quality is not one-size-fits-all. It’s about being flexible. What a unit needs today, at Dr. Dolan’s organization, may not be what that same unit needs six months from now.
Think about the evolution of patient care and how much more complex patients are. You have to be able to ebb and flow to meet those needs, which is super hard to do unless you’re integrated and embedded in the organization that you’re partnering with.
When you have those strong relationships and that level of integration, you can really shift alongside the facility, help meet their needs, and even suggest things proactively.
I love Dr. Dolan’s example. Maybe we notice that our clinicians are saying the patients on this med-surg unit are becoming more complex. Are we sort of reaching into more of a telemetry-type skill set now? Sometimes we’re driving that strategic conversation.
And I love that we are doing this during Nurses Week because you can see how clinicians, even our travelers, can contribute to the culture if they’re set up for success. They mitigate the turnover at our partners’ facilities if they’re well-staffed, and ultimately support the core staff and the morale.
When they are all set up for success, their ability to learn and be successful creates a better work environment for all and absolutely better patient care, which is what we all want.
KRISTIN
Yeah, absolutely.
Shifting gears a little bit here, for those who listened, our last episode focused on reactive staffing decisions. We spoke with Chase Farmer, our Chief Commercial Officer, and Erin McKenzie, our VP of Solution Engineering. They talked about the hidden cost of reactive staffing decisions and what healthcare organizations can do to avoid some of those pitfalls.
Karin, from your perspective, how important is it for partners to anticipate challenges rather than react to them, and how can they go about doing that?
KARIN
Yeah, definitely. First of all, it’s super important. I’m sure Dr. Dolan agrees that the best partners are those that anticipate for you and guide you in the right direction.
One simple example that I can think of, that my team and I are constantly having to monitor, is rates, scarcity of roles, or availability of the right talent in a certain location. It’s our job to keep monitoring the market. We have such vast access to information through all of the clients that we service, and that information is powerful for our clients to know and for us to bring to them.
We can share, “Hey, we’re seeing these needs in these markets. We looked at your historical data, and we anticipate you need X amount of roles,” for instance. That’s the kind of proactive, not reactive, information that we should bring to our clients as a partner.
KRISTIN
A lot of what you said leads into my next question. It goes beyond that business relationship into the human side of partnership: having those conversations and open communication.
Natalie, I’m curious, from a clinical perspective, how important is that human communication and connection?
NATALIE
The human connection aspect of partnership is irreplaceable. It’s table stakes at this point.
There are a lot of exciting, bright and shiny toys out there. When you look at AI and technology, it’s easy to get really distracted by that. The innovations can transform our workforce, so I think it’s natural that we’re leaning into that to really help our partners and help stabilize the workforce.
But you can’t lose sight of the human side of things, or we won’t be successful. Today, it really has to be both. You have to be advancing technology to support predictive analytics for our partners, like Dr. Dolan said, helping drive some of the changes maybe before they know about it.
But you also need to keep your white-glove service and your human support that sustains the partnership the entire way. The work being done is supported by that human connection.
When you really bring those two things together, the tech and human connection, that’s the model that’s going to support and scale, protect our patients, and make a staffing partner differentiated from the rest.
KRISTIN
We’re about 20 minutes in, and I was waiting for the first mention of AI. It’s hard to have a conversation these days without bringing up AI, so I appreciate you mentioning that, Natalie.
I also wanted to get Karin’s perspective. Can you expand on that a little bit, on the right way to build relationships that go beyond contracts?
KARIN
I think it’s all about walking the talk. It’s about consistency. It’s about reliability. It’s also being accessible, making sure our teams are always available when our clients need us.
And communication. I think it is tremendously important that we are clearly communicating on a frequent basis with each other and simply executing to the best of our abilities.
Honestly, I think it’s the hardest part, but it’s so critical to build relationships and trust. To me, that is the one thing that makes or breaks the best relationships.
KRISTIN
Yeah. There may be some leaders out there who are listening and hearing some of this and thinking, wow, I am not experiencing that with my current workforce partner or staffing vendor.
But switching partners can feel risky, and it can be a lot of work. So Dr. Dolan, can you talk about why it’s worth the shift from a staffing vendor to more of a workforce solutions partnership?
- DOLAN
Yeah. I’ll take you guys back in time for a minute.
When I was at another health system, I truly dealt with transactional workforce vendors, plural. The challenge was there was never a connection. There were never the detailed conversations or the relationships.
In this integrated partnership, I know my people and they know me. I consider them our employees. They’re part of our team. I don’t see them any differently. They’re just not here in this building.
For me, that is critical. You have to have that connection. You need to have that integrated partner. The transactional vendor doesn’t work. As an executive at another system where I had that, it was miserable. We did not have good outcomes. We did not have open dialogue.
And it’s not about the contract. That’s a piece of paper. Sometimes the contracts aren’t worth what they’re written on.
But I can tell you, when you have an integrated partnership, I don’t even think about the contract. It doesn’t cross my mind. I don’t say to myself, “Well, let’s go pull out the contract and remind ourselves what the expectations are.”
Our expectations are bidirectional with our integrated partners. There’s no guessing. There’s no ambiguity. There’s no blurriness. We know, and we treat each other like we’re each other’s partners, because we are. That’s how it needs to be.
KRISTIN
Well, this has been a great discussion. Before we wrap up, I’d love to hear one key takeaway from each of you.
For our listeners, what’s the one thing you would like them to take from this conversation?
KARIN
First of all, I want to say that I love what Dr. Dolan said about not wanting to look at the contract. I couldn’t agree with you more. I’d rather never look at contracts and truly deal with the issues at hand on a bilateral basis and have a good relationship. So I really echo that.
My key takeaway from this discussion that I really want to hone in on is to be open about your pain points and your organizational goals to be achieved.
The better we, as a partner, understand your organization, your goals, and your pain points, the better partner we can be. And the more we can tailor our workforce solutions to your specific needs.
That’s not always an easy thing to achieve. We have many partners that keep their cards close to their chest, and that makes it more difficult. And I understand that. There are always circumstances like that.
The partnerships that I can think of, also in my past life in different industries, are those partnerships where we can be very transparent with each other and build that trust. As a result, we have a common understanding of the goals that need to get done.
And as you say, Dr. Dolan, we become an extension of your team. That’s when we are most successful.
KRISTIN
Natalie, do you want to go next?
NATALIE
Yeah. Kind of jumping off of what Karin said too, back to the one-size-fits-all point, you have to have a partner that’s really willing to dig in and understand what your unique needs are, and is able to ebb and flow with you and drive some of the strategy alongside you.
If you really have that synergy and that true partnership, it trickles down to the unit level, down to the staff. They really can feel that, and that ultimately leads to better outcomes and better patient care.
KRISTIN
Thank you. Dr. Dolan, last but not least.
- DOLAN
I think my key takeaway for all healthcare executives or leaders out there who have a partner and maybe you’re not happy with that partner is to go find one that will do what you need. They do exist. I can attest to that.
We’ve been in a long-standing integrated relationship, and I would say don’t tolerate mediocrity from your vendors if they’re not meeting your needs. Don’t be afraid to change. I know as human beings we don’t like change, but it’s okay to go find a vendor that’s going to meet your needs and integrate fully with you.
Again, back to what everyone else is saying, it has to be open and transparent. They can’t help us if we’re not transparent about the reality, and we can’t help them if they’re not transparent. It’s really a bidirectional relationship. And that’s what it is. It’s a relationship.
So that’s what I would say to anyone. If you feel like you’re in a place that’s not working for you, take the leap. Go find a partner. Spend some time. Don’t look at the numbers. Don’t chase the contract and the legalese. See who fits with you.
If you can talk to that other partner and you’re like, “That’s them,” you’ll know. That’s what I can say about our long-standing relationship with our integrated partner.
KRISTIN
Great advice and a great note to end on.
This has been such a valuable conversation. What we’re hearing loud and clear is that the future of workforce solutions isn’t transactional, it’s relational. It’s about shared accountability, proactive problem-solving, and a deep alignment with the goals that matter most: supporting clinicians and, of course, delivering exceptional patient care.
Thank you to Karin, Natalie, and Dr. Dolan for sharing your insights and perspectives.
KARIN, NATALIE AND DR. DOLAN
Thank you.
KRISTIN
And thank you to our listeners for joining us on Healthcare Workforce Unplugged. If you found this conversation valuable, be sure to subscribe and share it with your colleagues.
For more information on Medical Solutions, head over to our website, medicalsolutions.com. We’ll see you next time.